X-COM: UFO Defense vs. XCOM: Enemy Unknown - Using gameplay design patterns to understand game remakes
نویسندگان
چکیده
We analyze X-COM: UFO Defense and its successful remake XCOM: Enemy Unknown to understand how remakes can repropose a concept across decades, updating most mechanics, and yet retain the dynamic and aesthetic values that defined the original experience. We use gameplay design patterns along with the MDA framework to understand the changes, identifying an unchanged core among a multitude of differences. We argue that two forces polarize the context within which the new game was designed, simultaneously guaranteeing a sameness of experience across the two games and at the same time pushing for radical changes. The first force, which resists the push for an updated experience, can be described as experiential isomorphism, or “sameness of form” in terms of related Gestalt qualities. The second force is generated by the necessity to update the usability of the design, aligning it to a current usability paradigm. We employ game usability heuristics (PLAY) to evaluate aesthetic patterns present in both games, and to understand the implicit vector for change. Our finding is that while patterns on the mechanical and to a slight degree the dynamic levels change between the games, the same aesthetic patterns are present in both, but produced through different means. The method we use offers new understanding of how sequels and remakes of games can change significantly from their originals while still giving rise to similar experiences.
منابع مشابه
“Who am I now?” Sense of Gender and Place in Digital Gameplay
In this essay I analyze the ways in which gender and space are shaped and made sense of through digital gameplay. Specifically in the turn based strategy game XCOM: Enemy Within for the MacBook Air with a computer mouse as the primary input device. Using a mixed methods approach consisting of gameplay sessions of XCOM and qualitative interviews with two players regarding their gameplay I argue ...
متن کاملSplit Appearance. Patchy and Coherent Features in Fragments of Gameplay, Mohenjo-daro, Sindh
This paper centers on ancient, generally rather scattered and elusive remains of gameplay. Focusing on a discreteassemblage of game-related artefacts from the Bronze Age Indus Valley urban settlement of Mohenjo-daro, it conductsa detailed study of some of the patchy features to see whether more structured elements thereby can be distinguished.The finds are approached situated in a broader, game...
متن کاملThe State of the Art and the State of the Practice
A game theoretic approach to threat intent inference In the adversarial military environment, it is important to efficiently and promptly predict the enemy’s tactical intent from the lower level spatial and temporal information. In this paper, we propose a decentralized Markov game (MG) theoretic approach to estimate the belief of each possible enemy COA (ECOA), which is utilized to model the a...
متن کاملThe 'extrapolated center of mass' concept suggests a simple control of balance in walking.
Next to position x and velocity v of the whole body center of mass (CoM) the 'extrapolated center of mass' (XcoM) can be introduced: xi = chi + nu/omega 0, where omega 0 is a constant related to stature. Based on the inverted pendulum model of balance, the XcoM enables to formulate the requirements for stable walking in a relatively simple form. In a very simple walking model, with the effects ...
متن کامل